Timeless Indulgence
Experience the unmatched indulgence of handcrafted pies, where rich brown butter and 40 years of baking mastery create the perfect centerpiece for any occasion.
About Our Pies
At Sissy's Artisanal Brown Butter & Classic Pie Company, proudly made and sold in Santa Cruz County, we don't just bake pies--we create delicious culinary works of craftmanship that bring people together. Each pie is crafted with uncompromising quality, care, and thoughtfulness, ensuring that every pie is a moment to savor.
Our pies are baked to order—not mass-produced—ensuring that every pie is a unique, artisanal creation with its own distinctive character. Each one is hand-shaped with intention, ensuring that every crust, every fold, every distinctive sweet juicy filling, and every golden-brown edge is a testament to true artistry. No two pies look exactly the same because real craftsmanship doesn't come from a machine; it comes from skilled hands.
These are enticing, scrumptious pies you'll be proud to serve and delighted to share.
About Sissy
At Sissy's Artisanal Brown Butter & Classic Pie Company, every pie is a labor of love, inspired by a lifetime of baking and tradition.
The name “Sissy” comes from a childhood nickname given to our founder by her older brothers, evoking warmth, family, and the joy of homemade pies.
Our journey began over 40 years ago when our founder embarked on a mission—baking one pie each week for an entire year until she mastered the perfect crust and filling.
Our brown butter-infused creations set us apart, delivering depth, richness, and warmth that elevate every bite. Every pie is made with thoughtful precision and a passion for perfection, ensuring a truly indulgent experience that keeps people coming back.
From family gatherings to fine dining tables across Santa Cruz County, these pies have been beloved for decades and are now available to share with you.
Quality & Handcrafted
We believe that the best pies come from quality ingredients, skilled hands, and time-honored techniques. At Sissy’s Artisanal Brown Butter & Classic Pie Company, we make a select number of pies each week, ensuring that every pie we sell is fresh, delicious, and made with meticulous attention to detail.
Each pie has its own character—no two crusts are identical, and no two fillings settle exactly the same way. That’s the beauty of artisanal baking. The handcrafted nature of our pies is a reflection of the care we put into every step, making each one as unique as the person who enjoys it.